• Home
  • Country Index
  • About US
  • Contact

Immigration World

The World Has No Boundaries

  • Canada
  • Dubai
  • France
  • India
  • Italy
  • Sweden
  • UK
  • USA
  • etc
  • Country Index

Home » USA » Denials And Delays Of H1B Visa Processing – Lawsuit Against USCIS

Denials And Delays Of H1B Visa Processing – Lawsuit Against USCIS

May 25, 2019 by Filter Coffee

  • Mass litigation campaign filed by ITServe against the USCIS challenging the new visa regulations
  • US District Court not persuaded by USCIS arguments on the need for ‘guaranteed work assignments’
  • USCIS to submit an explanation for issues with H1B visa processing within 2 weeks

Recent changes in the H1B visa policy have led to a number of applications being denied and delayed. IT companies have been hit the hardest by this.

A lawsuit filed by ITServe Alliance, a coalition of IT companies in the USA has resulted in a US District Court judge ordering the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to explain the delays and denials of H1B processing.

H1B visa, HiB Visa Fee, H1B Visa Processing , H1B Changes , H1B Visa Extension, H1B Visa Application, Deny H1B Visa , H1B Visa Applications Drop , H1B Visa, H1-B Visa extension, H1B Visa Rules
H1B Visa

ITServe Vs United States – Background To The Lawsuit

In February 2018, the USCIS issued a memorandum for IT companies to meet a number of new requirements when placing employees with H1B visas at third-party client sites.

When applying for new H1B visas or renewals of existing visas, these companies would also have to prove ‘guaranteed specific and non-speculative work assignments’ for the length of time the visa would be issued for.

This typically is about 3 years. For this, the companies would have to submit evidence in the form of the employee’s itinerary and detailed customer contracts.

In addition, the employer would also have to prove that the employer-employee relationship will be maintained even when the employee is at a client site.

As a result of these new regulations, the processing of applications was delayed considerably. A number of H1b were issued for a much shorter duration than the regular 3 year period. This ranged from a few weeks to a few months.

There was also a drastic increase in the number of H1B visa denials. According to one report, the H1B visa denial rate for IT service companies in the fiscal year ending 2018 ranged from 20% to 80% while it was only around 1% for non-service companies.

Companies that are part of the ITServe Alliance individually filed lawsuits challenging the legality of the new rules and denial of H1B visas. However, these typically resulted only in the USCIS reopening and reapproving petitions to avoid a judicial review of the new policies introduced.

While this did provide relief for the individual plaintiffs, it did not prevent the USCIS from continuing to do as it liked.

Why The Lawsuit?

When the individual lawsuits did not succeed in bringing about change in the USCIS policy, ITServe and its member companies conducted a mass litigation campaign along with attorney Jonathan Wasden.

Since the cases had overlapping legal issues, the US District Court for the District of Columbia ordered them to be consolidated under the name “ITSERVICE ALLIANCE v. CISSNA, D.D.C.18-cv-2350”.

This was designed at forcing the USCIS to defend their new policies in open court. Through this campaign, ITServe challenged the legality of:

  • The USCIS policy to increase the amount of evidence companies employing H1B visa holders at client locations had to provide in relation to the evidence needed by companies employing H1B visa holders at their own sites.
  • The need for medical/nurse staffing companies and IT consulting firms to prove “guaranteed specific and non-speculative work assignments” for the complete 3-year duration of the H1B visa.
  • The power of the USCIS to randomly decide how long the H1b visa would be valid for. In some cases, visas have been approved for only 1 day at a time. This has made employers pay additional fees to submit H1B vise extension petitions and kept the companies from utilizing the full potential of the employee.

The matter was heard by Judge Rosemary M Collyer who expressed skepticism over the USCIS’s argument that the new rules merely re-interpreted the existing visa policy.

The district court judge was also not persuaded by the USCIS’s argument over the legality of the ‘Employer-Employee Relationship’ test and the need for IT service companies to give ‘guaranteed work assignments’.

The judge observed that the employer letter submitted along with the H1B visa petition and the labor condition application form should prove that a job is guaranteed and hence fulfills the basic statutory requirement. In addition, the court noted that the USCIS demand for a guaranteed work assignment for the entire three year period is unreasonable.

The court has demanded an explanation from the USCIS on the need to prove ‘guaranteed specific and non-speculative work assignment’ for the complete three-year H1B visa duration.

An explanation has also been sought for the denials and delays of H1B visa petitions. The USCIS has been given two weeks to submit these explanations.

Also See

  • How to Apply for H1B Visa Extensions
  • H1B Visa Petitions to be Submitted Electronically
  • H1B Changes Announced in 2018 – A Complete List
  • Will Citizenship get Easier for H1B Visa Holders?
  • What Are The Common Reasons For USCIS Issuing An H1B RFE?
  • Premium Processing Of H1B Visa: Fewer Takers Among Indian IT Firms
×

Filed Under: USA Tagged With: H1B Visa, US immigration, US work permit

Follow US

Recent Posts

  • Everything You Should Know About The European Travel Information And Authorization System Or ETIAS
  • How To Get An Italian Startup Visa Or ISV
  • What Is The UK’s New High Potential Individual Visa Or HPI Visa?
  • Indian Entrepreneurs Have New Foreign Destinations In Sight
  • Setting Up A Business In Spain – You’ll Need A Spanish Entrepreneur Visa

Top Posts & Pages

  • 9 Countries Indians Can Easily Get Permanent Residency
  • OCI Card For Infants - How To Apply For An Child’s OCI Card
  • Indian Students Studying Abroad – The Latest Statistics
  • Ways to Migrate to Singapore
  • 5 Ways To Get Swedish Citizenship
  • Top 10 Countries Where You Can Immigrate and Settle Easily
  • How To Migrate To Malaysia
  • China Immigration - Eligibility, Job Opportunities and How to Apply
  • Tax Filing In Germany For International Students – Do All International Students Need To File Tax?
  • How To Migrate To The UK From The USA

Tags

business visa Canada Immigration Canada student visa citizenship citizenship by birth citizenship test Coronavirus cost of living EB5 visa Green Cards H-1B visa H1B Visa H1B visa Policy H4 visa immigrate to immigration and settlement Indian e-visa indian immigrants indian students International Students investor visa Migrate to New Zealand student visa no visa travel passports Permanent Residency Schengen Visa start up visa Student Visa Study in USA Tax Filing For International Students tourist attraction tourist visa travel ban travel tips UK immigration UK Visa USA Green Card usa immigration USA student visa USA Visa US citizenship US immigration US work permit work visa
Feedback | Disclaimer
Copyright © 2022 immigrationworld.com.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
Do not sell my personal information.
SettingsAccept
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
 

Loading Comments...